Kevin Shattenkirk by Bridget Samuels
SmHero(3)

The Case Against Kevin $hattenkirk

Making this type of free agent splash almost certainly means a buyout of Marc Staal and/or Dan Girardi, but the ripple effect goes beyond the two veterans. It’s hard to imagine a scenario where Jeff Gorton spends big on Shattenkirk and then shells out another $4 million or so for Brendan Smith. If that’s the case, then we’re all but guaranteed one of Nick Holden, Marc Staal, or Dan Girardi spending another year in the top four. Perhaps a new face, namely Ryan Graves, Neal Pionk, or Alexei Bereglazov can cement a spot, but that’s likely wishful thinking at this point as only Graves has ever played professional hockey in North America.

The pure cost and trickle-down effect in the lineup make a Shattenkirk contract a tough sell. That’s compounded by the fact that, despite all he does well, he’s never been a top-pairing shutdown defenseman and doesn’t have the skins on the wall to warrant such a promotion in New York.

SmHero(3)

That Raanta is So Hot Right Now

The Flames aren’t especially pressured by Vegas expansion, but they do need a goaltender to protect as their starter, with both Brian Elliott and Chad Johnson being UFAs this summer. Raanta and his especially easy to digest $1M AAV for next season would be an ideal financial scenario for a Flames team with nearly $30M tied up in six forwards (Gaudreau, Monahan, Brouwer, Frolic, Backlund, Stajan) and another $20M-plus in four defensemen (Giordano, Hamilton, Brodie, Engelland) next season. Like was the case with Talbot and the Oilers, too, acquiring Raanta with a year left on his contract would give them the added benefit of taking him for a test drive as a starter for the first time in his career before committing to a long-term extension. This is an advantage they simply wouldn’t have should they wait to see if he makes it to Unrestricted Free Agency in the summer of 2018.

Perhaps the Rangers might try to take another run at Dougie Hamilton, who found his name churning through the rumor mill last season, who would no doubt compliment Ryan McDonagh’s flank like nothing he’s experienced thus far through his Rangers career. Raanta won’t accomplish that feat alone, but it’s possible he could be a feature in a larger package to bring the Toronto native to New York City. I’m sure the Flames would have plenty of interest in acquiring Kevin Hayes as a means to reunite him with his Boston College running mate, Johnny Gaudreau. The two are currently playing together again for Team USA at the 2017 IIHF World Championship games giving Flames’ GM Brad Treliving an idea of the kind of chemistry the two forwards share.